Property Management in Lake Mary, FL
Lake Mary is consistently ranked among Florida's best places to live — a polished Seminole County city built around its corporate corridor, where professionals renting near work expect quality homes and responsive management. It's a market that rewards owners who present well and screens carefully: tenant expectations are high, and so is tenant quality. Newberry Property Management serves Lake Mary and the Greater Orlando area with the same locally-owned standards that have defined us since 2014.
The Lake Mary Rental Market
Lake Mary's rental demand is anchored by its employment base — the financial services and tech employers along the I-4 corridor draw relocation tenants, remote professionals, and executives who want short commutes and excellent schools. Rental demand concentrates in well-kept single-family homes and townhome communities, and tenants here compare properties seriously before applying.
That tenant profile cuts both ways: well-managed Lake Mary properties attract stable, high-income applicants who renew year after year. A property that's dated, mispriced, or managed carelessly sits — in a market this discerning, the management quality is part of the product. Our pricing, marketing, and screening process is built for exactly this kind of market.
Why Lake Mary Property Owners Choose Newberry
- Presentation-first leasing: Strategic pricing and professional marketing that position your Lake Mary home against the comparables tenants are touring the same weekend.
- Executive-grade screening: Credit, background, income, rental history, and pet checks — calibrated for a market where applicant quality is high and worth protecting.
- Transparent, published pricing: Leasing-Only (100% of first month's rent), Full Management (40% + 10% monthly), Home Away ($100/visit).
- Locally-owned accountability: A Central Florida team since 2014 — direct access to the people managing your property.
- Renewal-focused management: In a market of quality tenants, keeping them is the highest-return work we do.
Areas we serve
Timacuan, Heathrow area, Lake Mary Boulevard corridor, Colonial TownPark, Markham Woods corridor
Frequently Asked Questions
How much does property management cost in Lake Mary?
Our plans are published upfront: Leasing-Only (100% of the first month's rent), Full Management (40% placement fee plus 10% of monthly rent collected), and Home Away Services ($100 per visit). A free rental analysis comes first so you know what your Lake Mary property should earn.
Do you serve Seminole County?
Yes. Newberry serves Greater Orlando including Lake Mary, Sanford, Winter Park, and Altamonte Springs, alongside all of Volusia County. Lake Mary owners also get one team for properties anywhere in that footprint.
What kind of tenants apply for rentals in Lake Mary?
Lake Mary draws corporate relocation tenants, healthcare and finance professionals, and families seeking top Seminole County schools. These are high-quality applicants — and our screening ensures the one you place is the best of them.
Nearby areas we also manage
Sanford, Heathrow, Winter Springs, Altamonte Springs, Orlando